Aug
22
David on the All Stars Finale: The Toast Goes To…
David breaks down the designs and the final decision. Plus, inside intel from the judging room.
Here’s what David had to say from the set:
Do you agree with David (and the judges)? Did the right designer win? Weigh in in the comments below.
I'm sorry Design Star judges, but you are wrong. Hilari was the clear winner. I fail to see where Leslie has the scope of range to keep viewers tuned in. The murphy bed was expected, the space was cluttered, the color was too dark, it lacked function, and I did not think it would appeal to adults. This is just my personal opinion. HGTV, you made a blunder, and I'm happy to see that I am not the only one who thinks so. Do not be surprised when viewers don't go online to watch Leslie. I am sure she does great work, and she's a lovely lady, but this was not her win. Good Luck Hilari, and I hope to see you on HGTV again, you do beautiful work!!
I love Hilari and I think she deserved to win. I thought if Hilari didn't win, it would be Tom and low and behold Leslie won. I think they're all talented, but Hilari was the best.
I am so disappointed that Hilarie did not win. She brought something really interesting and different including a separate sleeping area.
I am surprised that none of them really used the outside space more. And no kitchen area at all??
FINALLY!!! Someone else wonders where the kitchen might have been, (even a galley along the window wall would have been really cool), not to mention a bathroom… and that outdoor space just beggedbeggedbegged to be used for something other than a bistro table and chairs…….having always lived in very small spaces, it makes sense to me to utilize every single inch to the nnnth degree. Still wondering how the judges came to their final decision with a murphy bed that was obviously so uncomfortable; it makes my back ache just thinking about it. Now if there was a main house you could run to and use the plumbing, etc, that's one thing, but still, there are those of us who must use every single inch to the best advantage for all purposes. I'd like to see Design Star decorate a 400 sf apt in NYC, thinking of every little thing that must be incorporated into that space, such as an office, bath, kitchen, living, entertaining areas/spaces…….and while we're on that subject, does everyone really entertain at home??? That seems like a throwback to the good old days of the 50's; now, everyone goes out, although I'd like to see that brought back home, front and center. HGTV: It's up to YOU!!! Mid-century design is back in vogue; pay attention, address the needs/desires of the masses, perhaps of baby boomers, for instance. Also, look at the responses you've gotten for over two months now…….and yet nothing new is on the horizon??? We're waiting……with bated breath….
Completely agree with the judges. Leslie's space was fabulous and she made extremely smart decisions with two days of time and over the course of the show. I also like Leslie's non-diva personality and maturity in taking responsibility for herself. While Hillary' work was fun and colorful, there are not many people who would want to live in a 20 x 10' bright Salmon space for very long. Thank you HGTV for recognizing talent and also someone who uses their design wisdom to be thoughtful about what people really need.
HILARI!!! All the way………………. What happened?
Definitely would want to watch a show done by hilari… Thought she should have won. I thought they all did great, Hilari just resonated with me more– love her personality & style.