• Share the Love

This week the popular social trends tracker, Buzzfeed, released their Top 15 Hottest Men of HGTV.  And, according to feedback on our social media, some of you think they were way off the mark with their line up.

So, we decided to get the definitive Top 15 from none other than the experts, our fans.  Take the Viewers’ Choice poll below and tell us which HGTV Hottie is your pick for #1!  We’ll post the official list on Friday.



97 Responses

  1. Silvia says:

    I live in Spain and in this moment The dream's House is on Tv. Enjoy, exceptionnal, fantastic …Jonathan &Drew the best !

  2. wendy denise furr says:

    yeah loev them property brothers they work hard and look handsome doin it!yall havea goldmine with jon and drewseky on ur teams…thanks fior makin us ladies smile each week

  3. Kim says:

    Jonathan and Drew definitely make the show more fun to watch especially when you see them playing with the kids! <3

  4. Carrie says:

    Jonathan and Drew all the way.. The brothers are hot!

  5. Sally Fuentes says:

    Please vote for Jonathan Silver Scott ty <3 <3 :)

  6. ana says:

    jonathan scott must be the number onebeee

  7. Eric says:

    Chip Wade hands down. love that guy!

  8. Daisy says:

    Anthony Carrino because ,he believes in hard work. Also, he has a tree tattoo. Tree of life means "Everything starts at the root!"

    • Jade Smith says:

      I don't find him handsome at all. He hardly smiles. Hate all of the tattoos and he is grimy looking. Also, he looks very full of himself.

  9. Robin McDowell says:

    Jonathan is my favorite but they are really neck and neck in my book like them both but Jonathan gets his hands dirty more.

  10. Elaine says:

    Jonathan and Drew! Love them! They are hot and funny!

  11. Renee hnatiw says:

    I can't stand how much I'm digging Jonathan!!!!

  12. Linda says:

    Love Chip. He's the best! Love his show.

  13. Maggie says:

    it was a toss up between Vern & David!

  14. Mary says:

    I love Jonathan, Chip and Scott but I am trying to figure out the name of the guy who came from All My Children…. I saw a few shows he did and he is sooo cute. I would love to see Jonathan, Chip and Scott and throw in the guy from All My Children do a show together…. my mouth would just water…. yummy

  15. MarshaMoore20 says:

    Jonathan definitely! He's so hot,he sizzles. Although it's the interaction between the twins that is really hilarious

  16. Maria says:

    Hi joy and from day 1 I saw you and I like you so much I know but I do not know ' how to make facts feel ok you are gorgeous and beautiful baci baci Mary found Sicily rated jonathan silver scott

  17. Chrissy C. says:

    Like always Drew Scott is my pick. Sexy and funny what could be a better mix. <3



  19. begoña says:

    For me Jonathan is the best is the guy most complete in every way but Drew also has a dot …. I'm from Barcelona

  20. Kathleen says:

    Now this is way much better than the BUZZ results. These are the choices from the fans. I don't know why Carter isn't a bit higher than he is, but he doesn't have that many shows on TV and that may be the issue.

  21. Melinda says:

    I wanna s…ck Drew Scott he is very sexy and i want too Johantan too :P :P :P :P

  22. sandrazgz76 says:

    Desde España voto a Jonathan Silver Scott, me encanta su programa

  23. Dianne says:

    Carter IS the hottest—you can just drown in those beautiful brown eyes!!

  24. GMS says:

    Jonathan Scott will forever be my #1. :D

  25. Debbie Nichols says:

    Carter Oosterhouse is gorgeous!!!

  26. mike starr says:

    thank you for pushing the cousins over and over and over all day. so we don't have to watch them any more we had plenty of that.

  27. Annie says:

    Jonathan and Drew are great guys…they are on my "bucket list". Hopefully I can meet them and maybe even cook for them. I love you guys!

  28. JD Scott says:

    haha This is just gonna go to Jonathan's head…and that thing is already big. No, I mean literally, we Scott's have large craniums.

    • Annie says:

      Been following Jonathan since his very first show…he really needs to win this, big head or not!! Ha

    • Mary says:

      I had the pleasure of meeting you JD and shaking your hand at the Phoenix Home Show. I got hugs from Jonathan and Drew and had my photo taken with them. I have to say in the photo that Jonathan's head appears to be larger than Drew's head. Has Jonathan's head always been bigger than Drew's head? I thought maybe Jonathan's head is larger because Drew sat on his head for 9 months.



  29. Peggy Eads says:

    Sitting here trying to come up with anyone anywhere who is hotter than Jonathan Silver Scott. What a total waste of time! What was I thinking??? There is no one!!!

  30. dqpamela34 says:

    Jonathan is truly # 1, than Drew Drew, and Scott McGillivray, all three my boys.

  31. brenda says:

    Scott, Scott, Scott!!!

  32. Carol Marie says:

    Yesterday Jonathan Silver Scott was over 50% now he's under. Drew Scott was over 22% now he's under, what gives hgtv!? #TeamJonathan #VoteJonathanSilverScott

  33. Zenaida Abugan says:

    I love Jamie Duries outdoor room projects!

  34. CLF says:

    Jonathan Scott is absolutely adorable!!!

  35. angelfromtheisland says:

    as I was voting I was apologizing to Drew LOL like he could hear me, LOL I was voting for his brother Jonathan, its the ruggedness he has about him and his smile, ok, its over all everything about him that is HOT! :) can't complain :)

  36. Cheryl G says:

    Wish I could've voted for more than one. But Jonathan is my dream guy.

  37. BrendaBreslin says:

    Jonathan and Drew(Hot Guys To View=HGTV). So that's where that came from. Duh.

  38. Rafaelle says:

    Jonathan and Drew!

  39. Love Scott G! says:

    Who is Jonathon Silver Scott? I watch HGTV all the time (except for the HIDEOUS "Love it or List It" and I have no idea who he is.

  40. Patti Staton says:

    Its impossible for me to choose just 1!! Just cant do it! HGTV has the most gorgeous MEN handsdown!!! So good luck to ALL of you!!!

  41. Geoffrey says:

    I'm disgusted with these results and feel that they're not very fair. John Colaneri is the hottest thing on ANY TV show since TV's inception! Jonathan and Drew need some shampoo and a razor. Then, they need to learn how to decorate with class and style.

    • Sally says:

      Excuse me?? Jonathan brings people's dreams to them, at a price they can afford, he not only can decorate with style but with better taste than what you most likely have in your own home, your just a hater because he has more class in his little finger than you in your whole body!!!!

    • Sadie Collins says:

      John Colaneri?! No way. Jonathan, Drew and Scott are by far the 3 hottest guys on HGTV.



  42. Debi McRoberts says:

    Scott McGillivray is the #1 most talented host on HGTV! No one else!

  43. Debi McRoberts says:

    NO! Scott McGillivray should be #1! He is the most talented.

  44. Linda says:

    I love the Scott Brothers, they are fun to watch. But the hottest guy to me is Scott McGillivray. I love the new opening for the show too, talk about sexy, and cute!!! Great show!

  45. Rachael says:

    What about Bill Beckwith from Curb Appeal? That smile is super sexy!

  46. Dianne Corriere says:

    Matt Muenster. My husband likes him too!

  47. Patty A says:

    Weston Coventry is awesome!

  48. Len says:

    Chip Wade…hands down…bald muscles never looked sexier !!

  49. Stef says:

    Can't go wrong with a Kitchen Cousin. Either or.

  50. Joellen says:

    Jonathan doesn't even have to pick up a tool. He can just stand there and think about it. l will always tune in. Hgtv can change the name to The Pondering Brothers.

  51. JenE says:

    You can't list 25 of your men and not include them on the poll!! Josh Temple and Matt Muenster are only write-ins and should easily be in the top 10!

  52. Kat V says:

    You are missing Bryan Baeumler. He's my choice!

  53. Virginia says:

    Some of these guys are very handsome but I don't get a chance to see their shows very often because of so many reruns of House Hunters and other boring shows on the HGTV channel. I haven't seen a Carter Oosterhouse or Cousins show in months!

  54. Liha says:

    Jamie Durie and the hot accent to boot!

  55. Kathie says:

    David Visentin is not even on the list and he is just great. Tommy Smythe is very good, too, and he is not on the list. Those are my 2 favorites.

  56. Connie Howell says:

    The Scott twins should b one, they look alike, soooo, they r out front !!!

  57. amy r says:

    It's so hard to pick just one!

  58. Kim Trickey says:

    It just proves that women (I am assuming) like a hot guy that can DO stuff around the house.

  59. Stephanie Young says:

    Jonathan and Drew Scott for sure!!! Not only are they incredibly attractive, they are amazingly talented in their crafts as well. Cannot say enough about all of their humanitarian endeavors……certainly they are very entertaining and I would expect nothing but good things for them in the future !! Overall, all of the guys are an impressive group!! Great job!! HGTV!!

  60. Grace Spacey says:

    I had to go with Scott McGillvray…not only as good looking as my son, but his show taught me how to turn the lower level of my townhouse into a furnished rental suite…the income pays for 1/2 my mortgage. Good looking and good with money…killer combo!

  61. Vivian Sabido says:

    Carter Oosterhouse is the most handsome and the sexiest guy so my vote goes to him!

  62. Oz Binah Channah says:

    Jonathan's been flattering me since I discovered, every day. He has been a friend to talk in his page, a channel of expression, an inspiration, a mentor, a model, an example, a dream, my dawn, and my sunset. His inner beauty is seldom seen all put together in one man. And his outer beauty is the most gentle and precious gift of pleasure to lift a girl's heart. He is not only the HOTTEST man of hgtv. It is his substance that's gotten him there. He is going to win with a major lead, fireworks and balloons.

  63. Billie says:

    Jonathan is my favorite from the list but Jason Cameron should have been on the list as well- Would love to have Jonathan working on the inside of my home and Jason on the outside–What a view it would be

  64. Elsie says:

    How in the world can you choose between Jonathan and Drew. They're both handsome, intelligent, funny and kind. Just like my twin boys (oops, men). I wouldn't be able to choose which of my twins is the best or cutest.

  65. Sadie Collins says:

    Jonathan and Drew Scott are do devastatingly handsome. Their height, their lips, their dimples, their hair. Their shows and talent are amazing too; the best and hottest designers on HGTV hands down.

  66. Jade Smith says:

    I love Scott also and the Property Brothers. They are hottest and most talented guys on HGTV. I don't see what the hype is about the Kitchen Cousins. I don't like the way they look and I don't like their designs and bad acting either.

  67. Shanah Cole says:

    I don't like Anthony's or John's muscle head looks. Carter is cute. Scott is cute, Juan is cute. My favorites though are the gorgeous brothers Jonathan and Scott.

  68. Marilyn says:

    I have a problem since I really love more than one of the guys. Love David, Jamie, Jonathan, too many each for a different reason. They're all top notch to me and I hope they all continue to make new shows. I'm always watching HGTV or DIY. Keep up the good work guys.

    • Mary says:

      When there is a contest for "people" to come in to win …. there should be a contest for maybe the top 5 of this sexiest men contest to see which one is a better contracter, to build something better than the other, lets see who is sexy and talented…. I just don't know who would be the judge… hey maybe one of us women who are voting for them, no money for winning all we need is a date in a luxury spot with the winner… lol

  69. Danna says:

    This is like choosing your favorite crayon in the big box! I love them all! You should have added Chico from Candices' group. That hair! OMG!

  70. Calamity Jane says:

    Carter while cute,,,, has the worst speaking voice ever… drops him off the list in my books…
    Scott McGillvary – has it all #1

  71. Shanah Cole says:

    Carter is cute but he does have a bad speaking voice. Another bad speaker is John. He speaks too loud & fast, like he drank ten 5 hr energy shots all at once. His hairline is going back pretty far too. Time for some Rogaine I think.

  72. Sadie Collins says:

    Are the sexy Property Brothers also fashion, skincare or fragrance models? Does anyone know? The more pictures of them I can see, the better ;)

  73. Sadie Collins says:

    Yikes, i just saw that that hideous picture of Anthony with the big Joshua tree tattoo. i am not a big fan of tattoos, but if you are going to sport one, at least have sexy defined abs.

  74. Shanah Cole says:

    What makes twins Drew and Jonathan so special and Property Brothers the best show on HGTV? Their combination of great looks, the way they talk and present themselves, their professionalism, their humor, their real estate knowledge, their design talent, their construction talent, their empathy towards their clients and their ability to make people's dreams come true at an affordable price. This is a VERY rare find and I guarantee that they will continue to be loved on HGTV for many years to come :)

  75. Nisame says:

    Jonathan and Drew are the best. Their TV programs are very entertaining and the brothers have style and good taste. Greetings from Spain.

  76. Jeannette says:

    John Gidding! He needs to be on HGTV more!!!!

  77. Jan says:

    Chip is not only cutie he is so talented.

  78. Nancy says:

    Let's not forget Steve Watson. He is pretty darn awesome to. Not only good looking but a down to earth nice kind of guy. Lets vote for him also.

  79. Janet Shaw says:

    Scott. McGillivray for sure!!

  80. Gorgeous and elegant shape liked it so much

  81. Rosemary says:

    Love you guys. Marvelous and rewarding work. How can I nominate a person for a house makeover? He's remarkable and worthy of this surprise.

  82. Kelly says:

    My two favorite hosts are Carter Oosterhouse and Chip Wade.

Latest Pins on Pinterest

  • Thanksgiving Centerpiece Ideas: Acorn Place Card Holder >>...

  • Thanksgiving Centerpiece Ideas: A Giving Tree >>...

  • Thanksgiving Centerpiece Ideas: Fall Harvest Centerpiece >>...

  • Thanksgiving centerpiece ideas: DIY Cornucopia >>...