• Share the Love

This week the popular social trends tracker, Buzzfeed, released their Top 15 Hottest Men of HGTV.  And, according to your feedback, you thought they were way off.

So, we asked you, the experts, to rank the hottest HGTV men of all time.  Here are your picks for Hottest HGTV Hotties

15.  Jamie Durie

Jamie Durie

Jamie Durie, “The Outdoor Room”

Digging Jamie?  Check out these beloved outdoor rooms from the show.


14.  Antonio Ballatore

Antonio Ballatore

Antonio Ballatore, “The Antonio Treatment”

Is Antonio your man?  Watch full episodes of “The Antonio Treatment” online now!


13.  John Colaneri

John Colaneri

John Colaneri, co-host of “Kitchen Cousins,” “Cousins on Call,” and “Cousins Undercover”

If this “Cousins” cutie is your fave, don’t miss the series premiere of Cousins Undercover October 6!


12.  David Bromstad

David Bromstad

David Bromstad, “Color Splash,” “HGTV Star”

Got designs on David?  Relive these vibrant transformations from the hit series, Color Splash.


11.  Todd Davis 

Todd Davis

Todd Davis, “Room Crashers”

Design Star finalist, the handsome Todd Davis, crashes and transforms outdated rooms across the country.


10.  Carter Oosterhouse

HGTV’s Carter Oosterhouse

Think Carter’s swoon-worthy?  See him in action here.


9.  John Gidding

John Gidding

John Gidding, “Curb Appeal: The Block”

Always a fan favorite, John wins over clients and viewers with his charm and design expertise.  Browse John’s most popular Curb Appeal makeovers.


8.  Vern Yip

Vern Yip

Vern Yip, “HGTV Star” judge

No one can resist a family man.  Check out this photo gallery of Vern at home with his kids.


7.  Chip Wade

Chip Wade

Chip Wade, “Elbow Room”

Handy with a hammer, renovation expert Chip Wade would be nice to have around the house.  We love these makeovers from HGTV’s Elbow Room!


6.  Chris Lambton 

Chris Lambton

Chris Lambton, “Going Yard”

Chris Lambton, professional landscaper — and fan favorite on ABC’s The Bachelorette — knows a thing or two about backyard makeovers. 


 5.  Juan Barbieri

Juan Barbieri

Juan Barbieri, “Power Broker”

Relatively new to the HGTV family, general contractor, Juan Barbieri (HGTV’s Power Broker) is already winning hearts with his passion for design.


4.  Anthony Carrino

Anthony Carrino

Anthony Carrino, “Kitchen Cousins,” “Cousins on Call,” “Cousins Undercover”

Viewers have been crushing on Carrino since the launch of Kitchen Cousins , the successful kitchen renovation series co-hosted with real-life cousin, John Colaneri.  Now, with several hit shows and special appearances on air, and another big series slated to premiere in October (Cousins Undercover), fans are showing no signs of cooling down anytime soon!


3.  Scott McGillivray

Scott McGillivray

Scott McGillivray, “Income Property”

Dubbed “Scottie McHottie” by fans, Scott McGillivray, host of HGTV’s Income Property charms viewers with his winning smile, can-do attitude, and expert renovation/design skills.


2.  Drew Scott 

Drew Scott

Drew Scott, “Property Brothers,” “Buying and Selling,” and “Brother Vs Brother”

It’s only fair that the other half of Property Brothers came in first runner up. As the slick-suited realtor, Drew calls himself the brain of the operation (often using his wit to slip away once construction begins!) If you love a man with smarts and style, it’s clear that Drew is your guy. Coming in 2nd place to Jonathan will sure stir up some more fun sibling rivalry – Brother vs. Brother, anyone?!


1.  Jonathan Silver Scott

Jonathan Silver Scott

Jonathan Silver Scott, “Property Brothers,” “Buying and Selling,” and “Brother Vs. Brother”

The masses have spoken! Yes, his smoulder is an uncanny likeness to that of a Disney prince charming, but it’s his impressive talent of turning any space into a dream home that really sweeps fans off their feet. Okay, and maybe his hair, and the fact that he’s an illusionist. Oh and his two cute dogs. And his humor. And his hair…


212 Responses

  1. Lucy Stern says:

    You got it right…. Love these guys…

  2. Terri Kaptain says:

    I have to agree with the top, except Carter should have been 4. That man is GORGEOUS!

  3. Saundra D. James says:

    This one is absolutely # 1!!!! Love him!!!

  4. Kathryn says:

    When does the new calendar come out???

  5. Debbie P says:

    Like the new, updated list. I still think Mike Holmes should have been on it someplace. Otherwise two thumbs up.

  6. Sharalee Insley says:

    While all of those faces are gorgeous , I have to say Anthony & Antonio are my favorite.

  7. Mercedes says:

    John Gidding is the best, great, brilliant ideas, warm and handsome and I follow in all show

  8. Pam Martin says:

    Job well done viewers! I agree!

  9. Pam Maxson says:

    I love the idea of a calendar! This is much better than the first list. Chip is much closer to the number one spot!

  10. Ami says:

    Vern Yip, really?

  11. Suzan Miller says:

    Scottie McHottie should have been no. 1

    • Pauline Shropshire says:

      Absolutely Scottie!!!! Then John Gidding….oh yeah….and btw: At least 3 of these guys should not even be on this list….My husband is 84, and looks better!!

  12. ada keyla gonzalez says:

    I love their show

  13. stephanie cauler says:

    well agree with most of the voting rankings …would change a couple up…but overall good!

  14. Kathy Hadley says:

    Scott McGillivray number 1! And Jamie Durie a close 2nd!

  15. Lisa says:

    Top 3 hotties are Canadian Guys!!! Just sayin'…

  16. Altha Schellenberg says:

    I thknk its sad that HGTV has had to play the sex card to boost ratings .I used to watch all the time but when you screwdriver over Paula I lost interest. So now I was watching again but this ends it for me.

  17. Sharon says:

    Obviously no one has Googled Jamie Duri or he wouldn't be last.

  18. sylvia says:

    Yup….top three are my favs love those guys watch them every chance I get. Got it all looks and brains, I wish they can renovate my house. " ))

  19. Sophia says:

    Scott McGillivray and Jonathan Scott are my top tied for first!! good list :D

  20. Dede says:

    WOW! Jonathon was my pick and then Drew but had you put this picture of Drew in during voting he might of beat out his brother! Just sayin

  21. goldie says:

    What happened to "Ed," from Love it or List it. He is by far the hottest man alive on these programs.

  22. BRENDA says:


  23. bernice saleh says:

    Scott McGillivray, “Income Property” is THE HOTTEST & SMARTEST. 2ND is John Gidding, he is so cute that I'd faint if that man ever even looked at me!!!

    • Jan says:

      When do all of the great looking guys return to HGTV? I am really tired of your schedule and have been for months.
      Bring back the designers and these great looking guys.
      Bummed out Fan.

  24. Dianne says:

    Who straight who is gay?

  25. Angi says:

    This list is a lot better than the original. I would not necessarily agree with the order and there are a couple that I would switch out for someone else but it is still better than it was.

  26. Jheald says:

    Scott McGillivray is by far the hottest and he can dance. checkout his video of his wedding reception on Youtube. II have to say the beefcake pictures of the Scott twins look better than they look on the show. In also think "the cousins" are hot and very manly.

  27. KittyMommy says:

    The TWINS WIN ♥ Hands Down LoL

  28. Man Lover says:

    Love em all but should have been Jamie!

  29. Amanda says:

    Where is Matt Muenster?!

  30. KittyMommy says:

    Scottie McHottie ♥ My 2nd Choice :-)

  31. KittyMommy says:

    John Gidding ♥ My Third Choice :-)

  32. Betty Kincaid says:

    I agree with the top two sexiest guys. I know that Jonathan & Drew are twins, but there is something about Jonathan. He is Number 1 on my list. Sexy, Sexy~Be

  33. JuNee says:

    Jamie Durie should have been #1, Scott McGillivray #2

  34. Denise says:

    Carter should be #1 #2 John Gidding, #3 David Bromstead…the rest can fall where they may. They are all hot!

  35. Colleen says:

    I have to agree the property brothers are pretty sexy… Women love a handy man, and a hot one is all the more better. All these men are great and easy on the eyes!!

  36. Sharon says:

    Scott McGillivary should and is number one in my book then John Gidding, Chip Wade, Carter Osterhause, then the Jonathan Scott and Drew Scott Jamie Dury, Anthony Carrino and cousin well lets face it they are all HOT!

  37. Tam Taylor says:

    This is much better but I still think Carter O. should be #1 any day of the week!!

  38. Ava says:

    This is a better list, though I think I might put Scott over the twins. But, oh how quickly we forget! What about Andrew Dan-Jumbo and Ty Pennington? They started the hotness on HGTV. And I have to reach over to the sister station DIY and choose Matt Muenster. He is too cute, can design AND build, and funny. The perfect package.

  39. Karen Mainor says:

    Not a single African-American Man among the hunks? What about Ahmad, the AA man from Yard Crashers? Or did they take him off the air? I don't watch HGTV anymore, since it started catering to the rich. Their home remodeling shows only deal with people who have hundreds of thousands of dollars to spend. And their home buyer shows went international and only deal with real estate a $1,000,000 and more. It offers nothing anymore for the middle class homeowner and the "eye candy" isn't enough to keep me as a regular viewer.

    • Lori says:

      They were on the list. Did you vote?

    • penster47 says:

      That has always bothered me about the makeovers. Most of these people can afford their own makeovers, what about the poor smucks that only need a porch or deck rebuilt, foundation on their home restructured, or new siding and maybe landscaping. Maybe just need their homes winterized so they can stay warm in the winter with out paying astronomical heating bills? The ones that would never get it done because they can't afford it. The seniors, (like me) who live on nothing but social security and would never be able.

  40. PatP says:

    I would have put Carter at number one; although we haven't seen him on tv in a long time!!!

  41. uteggs says:

    Agree for most part. one or two made me say UH?

  42. Tricia says:

    Where is the all time hottie Mike Holmes? No one can do a wife beater and overalls like he can!

  43. mary beth says:

    anthony carrino #1 for me..then drew and jonathon……i don't care from there!

  44. BrendaBreslin says:

    Great Personalities,Smarts and Looks. Congrats to Jonathan and Drew Scott!

  45. Debby says:

    That is so much better BUT Carter should of been 5th and John ( cousin) 6th Jonathan and Drew I could Watch all day and Scott, what a charmer! I love Hgtv and so does my husband! Jamie maybe should be higher too– it's not just looks it is intelligence and presentation,the top three have it all!!!!

  46. Nicole says:

    This is good Johnathan is my first choice. But SERIOUSLY when is Ahmed coming back? Can we get some diversity?!? My eyes like/need all types of candy!

  47. Christina says:

    There are only 3 men here that I find EXTREMELY Sexy. My #1 pick is Anthony, #2 is Scott & #3 is Jamie.

  48. Joe Anna O'Brien says:

    This is a much better and more accurate LIST!!!! WTG!

  49. Deborah says:

    I think they are all great lookers. I don't see how you can pick just one. I'm 65 yrs. old so what do I know. They would all be welcome at our home for Thanksgiving.

  50. Julie says:

    1) David Bromstad, 2) Carter, 3) Scott, 4) John Gidding, 5) Jonathon, 6) Drew, 7) Chip 8) Jamie 9)Everyone else except: Antonia Ballatore who is not a contender on this list or any other.

  51. Chantal says:

    Jonathan Scott, 1st place. He has a beautiful face. What a dream it would be to meet him.

  52. Carrie says:

    First of all… LOVE all of them! Why in the heck do you think I watch so much HGTV! LUV! But this list is a little wack. Jamie Durie should be MUCH higher in the list and what the heck happened to Eric Stromer? Of COURSE luv Carter and the Scott brothers and the Kitchen Cousins an come redo my kitchen ANYTIME!

  53. Suzanne says:

    Gotta say I agree but there were 2 you left out! Matt and Josh!!!???

  54. Lynn says:

    You thought that Antonio Ballatore and Todd Davis belongs on the list. They're not hot.

  55. BrendainKs says:

    What about Chris Grundy? That's my pick!

  56. Carol Marie says:

    Of course Jonathan and Drew won! We love them and will be loyal to them forever! They are the hottest, not just because of their great looks, but because they have a good heart and a great sense of humor! #TeamJonathan #PropertyBrothers #TeamDrew Jonathan and Drew know how to connect with their fans!

  57. Kaila says:

    The results are spot on…I was torn between Jonathan and Scott, though!

  58. Kathie says:

    I protest the fact that DAVID VISENTIN was not included on this list. He gets my vote and I bet tons of other people would have voted for him also. I also really like TOMMY SMYTHE of the Sarah Richardson shows. He would have gotten a lot of votes, too.

  59. Kathie says:

    PS I think Drew Scott's photo is hilarious!

  60. Jan coman says:

    Sick of love it or list it!

  61. beverly says:

    i think #3 Scott is the best

  62. MaryMc says:

    Carter Oosterhouse should be #3. Can you not SEE him????

  63. lynn says:

    I missed the vote, your photos of the two top winners are fantastic – though I have watched those two , John Gidding and Scott McGillivary rank higher than the Scott brothers!

  64. regina greene says:

    Yeop, those Scott bros are smoking hot!!!

  65. Carolyn Carline says:

    3 5 9

  66. SAndy says:

    I think David Bromstad should have been closer to the top.

  67. Oh, laws! This Southern girl has a case of the vapahs!

  68. Gloria says:

    Agree totally. A couple of them I wasn't familiar with but Jonathan and Drew Scott, definitely. I too like Mike Holmes, muscles and brains!

  69. Trish says:

    Jonathan has always been my #1 pick ever since him & his brother hit the tv. I just wanted to look at him and nothing else about what he do. Must stop now, my fantasy are getting the best of me! :)

  70. Bret says:

    Fine, but David Bromstad is hottest overall.

  71. Alison says:

    Carter and Scott get my vote!

  72. SharonLiz says:

    Two former Bachelor contestants on here…Chris & Juan. Had to google it as I was wondering why Juan looked so familiar. Anyway, I still don't think this order is correct towards the bottom half, but I love Drew & Jonathan & Scott McGillivray is pretty darn hot!

  73. sherry says:

    Team Jonathan, you rock!

  74. Rita Dian says:

    Sibling rivalry right at the top – Drew and Jonathan! :D

  75. RosSmiles (from NJ) says:

    MUCH, MUCH BETTER!!! Scott M. had to be in the top 5. The Scott twins are spot on!!! Chip should have come before Chris (Yard-Guy). Carter should have been a little higher, too. But you know what….I'd still buy a calendar.

  76. Brenda Starr says:

    #3 Scott
    beautiful man inside and out!

  77. Margaret says:

    awesum top 3 pics, but i wud have put Jonathon, Scott , than Drew :)
    but more so if there cud be a tie it wud be both Jonathon nd Scott……luv those men. yep yep

  78. Harlana says:

    nope it is still wrong!!!

  79. Carol says:

    All I want to know is what happened to Ahmed Hassan.

  80. Barbara Szady says:

    Love the cousins,John Gidding and Scott McGillivray they are toooo cute for words.

  81. Sondra says:

    I love all these guys. They are all great to me.

  82. Lisa Aublesmith says:

    Scott McGillivray is the man!!!!

  83. Yes I agree to most just don't know all of them… lol.

  84. ana says:

    My top list will go like this:
    1. Scott McGillvray
    2. Anthony Carrino
    3. Carter Oosten house
    4.Jamie Durie
    5. Chip Wade
    6. Jonathan Silver

    All super handsome and handy! what else can we ask for…

  85. Laura says:

    Carter should def be in top 3!

  86. Joanna says:

    What is hot about Vern Yip?

  87. Malaysia says:

    I prefer Drew to be my #1 pick

  88. Maggie Johnston says:

    Jonathan Scott, Scott McGillivray, Anthony Carrino, Carter Oosterhouse, John Colaneri. Top five, with Chip at #6. These are some good looking and talented men!!!

  89. Gina Helm says:

    Scottie Mchottie, is the best,for me any ways,he is hot and talented,what else can I ask for,and I'm in the business too,jajajaa.but I think you made the right decition,I like him too..good job.

  90. Maryann says:

    love me some SCOTT, but Anthony Carrino , hes hot too.

    • Sadie says:

      Hotter than the twins? The twins are like 6 ft 4 in, with beautiful light eyes and full lips. Anthony has none of that.

  91. martimeffordphotography says:

    My top three as well! Except Scottie McHottie would be number one. It's has as much to do with his down to earth attitude as much as that beautiful smile! I love when he is able to listen to couples who are stressed about a basement renovation & helps keep everyone calm. He comes across as a great guy with a big heart. LOVE him. LOVE that he is so professional with every detail & gives his homeowners a reno they can be proud of and that passes inspection! WHOO HOO!

    • Jen says:

      The voters got the top 3 right. The top 3 guys are not only hot, but have very magnetic personalities and are extremely talented and professional. It their great looks combined with their great personalities that made them the top 3 :)

  92. Beverly Hullender says:

    It IS hard to focus on the programs sometimes when there' s so much to look at otherwise! Just sayin'! :)

  93. Kahty says:

    I agree with one and two, from there not so much

  94. Kathleen says:

    As usual, HGTV did it right and allowed the viewers to vote. And you got it right on the money. Did you share the results with BUZZ and find out what they did wrong? That would be funny. Thanks HGTV for correcting a very annoying wrong. Boy oh boy the boys are beautiful. And yes, a calendar for sale, proceeds for something good, nice cause, would be fun. Just get them to agree and they all have to agree to wear the same costume as Drew Scott.

  95. Molly Strickland says:

    Did you mention Jonathan's eyes??!! His creativity, his sense of humor. . . . But it's really in his eyes!

  96. Maria says:

    Vern should have not made the list; he's a nice guy, but not a hottie. John, Anthony's cousin, should have been higher on the list and yes, Scott would be my number 1. There were a couple of other ones don't make the list, in my opinion.

  97. Sidney says:

    1. Scott, 2 John… Thanks for all the pictures. I wouldn't throw any of them back. LOL

  98. roaringwoman1 says:

    Carter should've been #1 with Scott McGilvray as #2. Those cousins could have been an interchangeable #3 and #4.
    Wonder if that's a requirement to get a job on HGTV…Must be attractive and/or hunky.

  99. Susan Palmer says:

    John Gidding for sure number one. Jonathon Scott next. Drew look like he's cheating again :) Anthony C. is right up there.

  100. Abbiejo says:

    Carter and Jaime should have been closer to the top 4 and 5 the others are just okay in my book.

  101. Margaret day says:


  102. Nancy says:

    Love them all – but have a particular heart beat for John Gidding – oh that smile of his – and – of course, Antonio – oh those blue eyes..

  103. karen says:

    Jonathan scott has that rugged sexiness to him. That I love in a man of course his votes prove most woman do also.His twin Drew brother has a more softer sexiness.

  104. Jess says:

    Jamie Durie last? A kitchen cousin and CARTER OOSTERHOUSE in the bottom? Have we lost our minds. That's not carter oosterhouse's best photo ever but please…have the voters ever watched him? My mom and I literally swoon! I'm disappointed. What were the ages of the voters on some of these?

    Plus the twin's photos are way "sexier" looking than the others…of course they would win.

    Seriously, vern, juan and chris? who voted? Carter, Jamie, John, don't be discouraged. The voters were mental.

  105. pat says:

    He might not have made the hottie list but my favorite male on HGTV has to be Tommy from Sarah's House, etc.

  106. linda says:

    Juan Barbieri – dont know him, havent seen him yet, he should not be in the list….. love all the rest in the top…..

  107. Linda H says:

    Hotties and they can FIX things, too …. {{{swoon}}}

  108. Liana says:

    The top 3 were are spot on: Jonathan, Drew and Scott. All three are such cuties with beautiful hair, eyes and pearly white smiles. Are you kidding me about #4 though? Anthony Carrino was like in 8th place a couple of hrs ago and then he miraculously appears at #4? Looks like the same people probably did a LOT of voting for him at the last minute. I am not saying that he is completely unattractive, I am just not a fan of shorter, stocky guys with a lot of tattoos. What turns me off most is though that annoying smug look that he usually has on his face: like he is the S—. Jaime should have been #4. He just looks so sexy in the above picture.

  109. Jessica says:

    John Giddings should have won. He's the complete package: brains, body, hair, smile, personality, sex appeal. Yes, complete package.

    • Liana says:

      I agree. John Giddings should definitely have made the top 5: with Jonathan, Drew, Scott and Jamie as the other 4. Those 5 five are truly HGTV hotties with those sexy eyes and lips.

    • Liana says:

      John G. is sexy too. Should have been in the top 5 too

  110. JJMD says:

    So where is Matt Muenster…he's the HOTTEST of them all…and the coolest dude ever!

  111. guest says:

    Number 15 should be number 1!

  112. terri says:

    We need an HGTV Hotties calendar !!! Proceeds can go to charity. I'd buy a dozen !!

  113. Soney says:

    #4 Anthony should be #1

  114. Beth says:

    Yep Jonathan Scott he is my choice as well. They all are truly awesome, but WHAT a hottie he is!! Love his decorating style too!!

  115. Linda says:

    Carter will always be my #1. How can you put Drew second to Jonathan, especially with that pic with his shirt off?

  116. Maria says:

    I wish I had known about the voting. Okay viewers, you did good! But I think that Carter should have made the top 5, he's so cute!

  117. Joy says:

    Carter should be in the top 3, if not #1.

  118. channy says:

    Anthony Carrino oh ya or Jonathan Scott eh!

  119. Debora says:

    Why is Drew shirtless – looks hot – but wrong!
    Jamie and Carter should be in the top five for sure!

  120. Kay says:

    I am still jonesing on Carter Oosterhouse, but the Property Brothers are a pair of cutie-pies for sure! If you had posted that half-nekkid pic of Drew Scott in the first article, he may have won. Swoon!

  121. Niki says:

    What about Josh Temple?

  122. Kelley says:

    1 – 5… Josh Temple, Mike Holmes, Scott McGillivray, John Gidding, Carter Oosterhouse.

  123. Simmy says:

    Wrong, wrong, wrong, Carter is # 1 he is the hottest!!!! Then Jonathan and Drew.

  124. Laura says:

    Still not right, you have my guy, Jamie Durie at 15. What????? He is # 1

  125. Laura says:

    Also, agree that Drew's picture is much better the second time around!

  126. Karina says:

    Great guys with amazing talent – all of them!!! Thanks for the inspiration!

  127. penster47 says:

    They are ALL adorable, but I have to say that David Bromstadt is the most adorable. The sexiest has to be Jamie!!!

  128. Kendra says:

    I'm sure someone has already pointed out that the top three are Canadian. We growth them very nice!

  129. Marcia says:

    I still think Andrew Dan Jumbo would be my choice.

  130. Sandra M says:

    Jonathan is #1 with me. He is so cute.

  131. DDScott says:

    Their mother should be SO proud!
    Two of the most handsome men. (I'm married
    To a Scott maybe were related ). :)

  132. Ke Rockwell says:

    Woo Hoo 3 gorgeous Canadians top the list! Do we know how to grow them or what! And it doesn't hurt that they're fantastic at what they do. :)

  133. sanduchi13 says:

    Jonathan, Scott, John and Carter. Can watch them all the time. Smart, really nice and good looking.

  134. S STORY says:

    Like it just like it is NOW.

  135. Aimee says:

    Yep. All good for me. Canadians in the top 3. Would have had Oosterhouse as 4, but that's nitpicky.

  136. NanaJan says:

    Does anyone else else think that Anthony Carrino looks like a young George Clooney? In addition, I think that the twins, Scott and Carter could all be models. Great looking guys, but more importantly all genuinely big hearted people it seems. Which is also the appeal of Mike Holmes. Thanks for the great work that all of you do!

    • Emmy says:

      I think the twins, Scott, Carter and Jamie all could be models for sure. They all have these amazing facial features and their bodies are lean and mean (very well defined but not overly muscular). Perfection.

  137. Rodney Thomas says:

    Antonio Ballatore & Anthony Carrino are pretty damn hot. Both are perfect specimens and project a strong but kind energy. When viewing them, all I can say is DAMN . . . . . that guy is fine.

  138. spychic says:

    you got the top 4 correct, but the rest, wow, don't think juan should even be in the top ten. but what i liked is comments on the first page in reply to someone asking who is gay. everyone was like…"who cares"

  139. Rodney Thomas says:

    Someone is missing. It's JASON from Desperate Lanscaping. That guy is perfection and has one of the best bodies and prettiest faces on TV.

  140. Deborah Donald says:

    love watching the scott brothers

  141. PammyPoo says:

    Vern Yip, David Bromstadt, John Gidding are openly gay (assuming this is a list voted on by women). And Ahmed Hassan should be on list as well as Mike Holmes.

  142. Patty says:

    I would have to say Scott McGillivray is my pick for #1 and John Gidding would be my second choice. All of these men are winners!

  143. Sarah says:

    I like the property brothers… my favorite is Jonathan Silver Scott because I just love his personality! :)

  144. Cassie says:

    Well, they should now have an HGTV contest on the guy who has it all: great looks, brains, a great personality (being down to earth, funny, caring) and incredible design and construction talent. In the end it's the whole package that makes a HGTV man sexy . They should also have one for the HGTV women. My #1 pick would be Nicole Curtis, The Rehab Addict. She is beautiful, intelligent and amazing with design and construction. I am stunned every time I watch the lovely, feminine Nicole do some serious hands on demo on a old run down house and then design/restore it so it looks so beautiful.

  145. Annie says:

    Way to go Jonathan! We love you!

  146. elaina says:

    Carter should be #1!!!!!! Then Scott McGillvray!!!

  147. Jill says:

    Although I like Jonathan, Anthony Carrino is first in my humble opinion.

    • Cassie says:

      Anthony with his body covered in tattoos and rugged look will appeal mostly to girls that like bad boys. Jonathan has a rugged look but as the same time he is so refined and gentle too. Generally, a guy like Jonathan will appeal to more women.

  148. M Heinz says:

    Agreed. Jonathan Scott has a certain dreamy charm that even his beefy twin brother can't match.

  149. Millie Kargol says:

    I am just glad I didn't have to make the choices!! I agree that Mike Holmes should be on here somewhere – he is very handsome! I would like to see this calendar!

  150. Kandice says:

    Hello…..? Where is MATT MUENSTER?????? He HAS to be one there and he is not :(

  151. hands down its johathan scott # 1 ive been around 60 years the only other good look men were elvis and sam ellit. maria dombrowski.

  152. Janette says:

    Oh my, they are all handsome but Scott McGillivray from Income Property is my pick for being knowledgeable and helpful to each client he has. Love you Scott and your family that you have shown on TV before and even helped your cousins.

  153. Joe says:

    I'd do them ALL!!!

  154. Eileen Sedlacek says:

    Scott McGillivray makes me smile…. Scott. You take number one.. Tough competition though!!

  155. Nate says:

    Its almost right! Antonio should have been in the top three. I love Jonathan and Drew, I just happen to want to wake in the arms of Antonio more then Jonathan's or Drew's.

  156. Evelyn says:

    They should all be in 1st PLACE in my book :)

  157. Ruth Deatley says:

    Don't forget Mike Holmes. Not only is he handsome but he is REAL!!

  158. Carole Miner says:

    I think it is a toss-up between Scott McGillivray and Jonathon Scott for #1. I would rank Anthony Carrino as #3, and Drew Scott as #4. But, we need a category for David on Love It or Lease It. He is not a hottie, but he is so funny I really enjoy watching him.

  159. holly says:

    Would have been my choices for top two. Either way would work for me!

  160. Julie says:

    I totally disagree with this poll! Who is Juan Barbieri anyway who beat out Carter Oosterhouse? Seriously?

  161. Corinne says:

    Jonathan is definitely #1! Love him! He looks like Flynn.

  162. peggy breakiron says:

    Carter is definitey the #1 Hottie!

  163. Cassaundra Gilchrist says:

    Here is the CORRECT ORDER: Carter Oosterhaus, Scott McGillivray, John Giddings, Anthony Carrino , Jonathan Scott, Drew Scott, and Chip Wade. They are all handsome men and talented as well. But, what happened to Mike Holmes (sexy older men who are talented are even more sexy) loll

  164. Cheryl says:

    I still think Anthony Carrino should be the winner he is so much hotter than both brothers any day I think who ever voted might want to have their eyes checked then vote again!!

    • Jen says:

      No way. Jonathan, Drew, Scott, Carter and Jamie are the hotties of HGTV. 20/20 vision here so no need to look or vote again.

  165. Liz says:

    I like the choice, But they should have been together. Love It HGTV, are they married?

  166. Gail says:

    Where is Mike Holmes?

  167. L. Herman says:

    Scott McGillvray is absolutely Number 1.

    • Jen says:

      Yes, he is very hot. He is one that had my eyes glued to the TV the few times that I saw him. He needs more shows/air time for sure though :)

  168. Jen says:

    The top 3 are spot on. Those 3 Canadian men are very sexy (road trip to Canada for me anytime!). The brothers are perfect looking in every way. They are just so sexy. Tall and lean, great hair, great smiles, great eyes, great cheekbones. I could go on and on about those two. They also have great chemistry working together, charm, refinement and very funny personalities. Their designs are beautiful and I honestly have not see a reno that I did not like. I also love their amazing ability to envision the potential of a house. I have seen Scott a few times and thought he had such a beautiful smile. I am not as familiar with his designs though because every time I turn on HGTV, I usually see Drew and Jonathan, Love it or List it or House Hunters. However, the times that I have seen Scott, I could literally not stop staring at the TV. The Kitchen Cousins I could do without, Carter has been around for a long time (TLC days) so he has the skills and years later is still very good looking. There is also something very sexy about Jamie Durie. My top 5: Jonathan, Drew, Scott, Carter and Jamie. They are definitely the hotties of HGTV :)

  169. Sydney Donovan says:

    I don't understand #4. I find him too rough around the edges- grungy looking and covered with tatts and he doesn't smile much. C'mon ladies, how is that a turn on? And the other cousin has this permanent smile literally glued onto his face all of the time. This list make absolutely no sense after #3.

  170. cindy says:

    Agree with 1-3, Carter should be 4 IMO.

  171. Barbara says:

    My number one choice would be, hands down, Scott McGillivray

  172. Dj91 says:

    4. Anthony Carrino for personal reason I' can't say eehehehhe he's got the rest beat lolol

Latest Pins on Pinterest

  • Thanksgiving Centerpiece Ideas: Acorn Place Card Holder >>...

  • Thanksgiving Centerpiece Ideas: A Giving Tree >>...

  • Thanksgiving Centerpiece Ideas: Fall Harvest Centerpiece >>...

  • Thanksgiving centerpiece ideas: DIY Cornucopia >>...